Restaurant Menus

Green Bay, WI

Family-Style Meals 

High-Quality Ingredients 

In-Store Pickup

Hours:


Finish Your Meal with Our Handcrafted Desserts

Our dessert menu features traditional Italian sweet treats made with the same dedication to quality that has defined Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant since 1958. Each dessert is prepared using quality ingredients and family recipes passed down since 1924. From classic tiramisu to rich cannoli, every item reflects 68 years of experience in authentic Italian cuisine. Available for in-store pickup, our desserts provide the perfect conclusion to any family-style meal.


Reach out to us for information about our current dessert selections.



Finish Your Meal with Our Handcrafted Desserts

Our dessert menu features traditional Italian sweet treats made with the same dedication to quality that has defined Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant since 1958. Each dessert is prepared using quality ingredients and family recipes passed down since 1924. From classic tiramisu to rich cannoli, every item reflects 68 years of experience in authentic Italian cuisine. Available for in-store pickup, our desserts provide the perfect conclusion to any family-style meal.


Reach out to us for information about our current dessert selections.


Sammy's Sensational Pizzas
Our pizzas are made from our own recipe, thin crust with only the freshest ingredients, including our famous homemade pizza sauce

and our family recipe Italian sausage! We proudly use only 100% real Wisconsin cheese.

10" (serves 1-2)   12" (serves 2-3)  14" (serves 3-4)  16" (serves 4-5)

*Gluten friendly crust available for upcharge*

10"  3.50   12" 4.50   14" 5.50

Pizza

Pizza

Sammy's Special

Mozzarella cheese and Italian sausage with a light touch of onion and diced green peppers.

10"
$15.45
12"
$20.95
14"
$25.45
16"
$28.95

Pizza

Crazy Italian

Family recipe Italian sausage, capicola, pepperoni, Genoa salami, pepperoncini, fresh garlic, and fresh basil, topped with mozzarella and asiago cheese.

10"
$17.95
12"
$23.45
14"
$27.95
16"
$31.45

Pizza

Classic Combo

Our most popular pizza, a perfect blend of our family recipe Italian sausage, sliced pepperoni, sweet onion, diced green pepper, mozzarella cheese, topped with your choice of canned or fresh mushrooms.

10"
$17.45
12"
$22.95
14"
$27.45
16"
$30.95

Pizza

Three Cheese

Mozzarella, Provolone, and Swiss cheese.

With optional fresh sliced garlic.

10"
$14.95
12"
$20.45
14"
$24.95
16"
$28.45

Pizza

Hawaiian

Canadian Bacon and pineapple on top of mozzarella cheese.

10"
$15.45
12"
$20.95
14"
$25.45
16"
$28.95

Pizza

Chicken Alfredo

Homemade Alfredo sauce covered with mozzarella cheese, chicken, bacon, and red onions.

10"
$16.45
12"
$21.95
14"
$26.45
16"
$29.95

Pizza

Vegetarian Pizza

Mozzarella cheese, onions, green peppers, tomatoes, black or green olives and your choice of canned or fresh mushrooms.

10"
$16.95
12"
$22.45
14"
$26.95
16"
$30.45

Pizza

The Carne

For all the meat lovers! Our seasoned ground beef, sliced pepperoni, Canadian bacon, spicy capicola, mild kosher salami, topped with mozzarella cheese and our family recipe Italian sausage.

10"
$17.95
12"
$23.45
14"
$27.95
16"
$31.45

Pizza

Margherita Pizza

An Italian classic with tomatoes, fresh basil leaves, fresh mozzarella cheese, olive oil, butter and garlic sauce on our homemade pizza crust.

10"
$14.45
12"
$19.95
14"
$24.45
16"
$27.95

Pizza

Taco

Our special taco sauce, seasoned beef, mozzarella and cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, with a light touch of black olives, and onions (Sour cream available upon request).

10"
$17.45
12"
$22.95
14"
$27.45
16"
$30.95

Pizza

House Special

Mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, beef, onions, Italian sausage, green peppers, a light touch of kosher salami, and your choice of canned or fresh mushrooms.

10"
$17.45
12"
$22.95
14"
$27.45
16"
$30.95

Pizza

Sausage Lovers

Twice as much of our famous family recipe sausage.

10"
$16.95
12"
$22.45
14"
$26.95
16"
$30.45

Pizza

Build Your Own

10"
$11.45
12"
$16.95
14"
$21.45
16"
$24.95

Premium Toppings

Pizza

Additional Toppings

10"
$1.50
12"
$1.75
14"
$2.25
16"
$3.00

Artichokes

Canned Mushrooms

Fresh Mushrooms

Black Olives

Green Olives

Tomatoes

Onions

Green Peppers

Roasted Red Peppers

Jalapenos

Pepperoncini

Fresh Garlic

Fresh Basil

Spinach

Pineapple

Asiago Cheese

Provolone Cheese

Swiss Cheese

Cheddar Cheese

Menu

Homemade Family Recipe Pasta

Plates include garlic bread. Dinners include garlic bread and fresh garden salad.

Choose your favorite sauce on any pasta order:

Classic Tomato Sauce • Tomato Cream Sauce • Spicy Garlic Marinara • Spicy Tomato Cream • Alfredo Sauce • Garlic Basil Pesto Sauce • Creamy Garlic Pesto Sauce • Bolognese Sauce

Spicy Tomato Cream Fettuccine

Homemade rich and spicy tomato cream sauce   over homemade fettuccine noodles. Served with your choice of homemade meatballs, family recipe sausage, or one of each.

Plate 14.95 Dinner 17.95
Spaghetti & Meatballs

Homemade spaghetti & meatballs with classic tomato sauce. Served with your choice of homemade meatballs, family recipe sausage, or one of each.

Plate 12.45 Dinner 15.45
Penne & Italian Sausage

Penne pasta served with homemade Italian sausage and creamy tomato sauce. Served with your choice of homemade meatballs, family recipe sausage, or one of each.

Plate 12.95 Dinner 15.95
Gnocchi

Our Family Recipe! Italian potato dumplings, served with classic tomato sauce and your choice of homemade meatballs, family recipe sausage, or one of each.

Plate 15.95 Dinner 18.95
Basil Pesto Penne

Homemade garlic pesto with penne pasta and sliced chicken breast.

Plate 14.45 Dinner 17.45
Spicy Garlic Marinara

Homemade garlic marinara with a touch of spice, served with homemade fettuccine pasta and your choice of homemade meatballs, our family recipe sausage, or one of each.

Plate 14.45 Dinner 17.45
Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo

Homemade fettuccine noodles topped with grilled chicken, covered in our creamy Alfredo sauce.

Plate 14.95 Dinner 17.95 Substitute Shrimp 3.95
Baked Penne

Penne covered with three of our homemade sauces mixed with ricotta cheese and topped with melted Provolone cheese. Served with your choice of homemade meatballs, family recipe sausage, or one of each.

Plate 16.95 Dinner 19.95
Family Pasta Dinner

Serves 4-6  54.95

Dine like you're at home - family style! Choose from any of our homemade pasta, Spaghetti, Fettuccine, Pappardelle, or Penne (excludes Gnoccchi), served in a large pasta bowl with Italian sausage and meatballs. Served with a large salad and hot breadsticks.

Menu

Sandwich Menu

Sammy's Pizza in Green Bay, WI, offers a wide range of sandwiches, including homemade Italian sausage and full-roasted Italian beef made in-house. Our tasty sandwiches are served on freshly baked bread with chips and a pickle.

Sub Sandwich Favorites

Served with chips and a pickle.

Italian Beef

Our family recipe Italian beef which is slow roasted for hours, served on warm Italian bread. 

$13.45
Sammy's Sub

A classic Italian sub served with our famous vinaigrette dressing, smoked ham, Genoa salami, melted provolone cheese, lettuce, and tomato.

$11.95
Italian Sausage Sub

Our family recipe Italian sausage, served with sauteed onions, roasted red peppers, melted provolone cheese, and covered in our homemade tomato sauce.

$12.95
Meatball Sub

Homemade meatballs with provolone cheese and our homemade tomato sauce. 

$12.45
Grilled Chicken Sub

Chicken breast strips, melted provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo.

$10.45
Smoked Turkey Ciabatta

Smoked turkey, lettuce, tomato, melted swiss cheese, and mayo

$10.45
Italian Ciabatta Sandwich

Cappicola, Genoa salami, pepperoni with provolone, pepperoncini, red onions and Italian mayo served on ciabatta bread.

$10.95
Half Sandwich

Your choice, served with soup or salad.

$11.45
Available until 4:00pm

Menu

Appetizers, Soups & Salad Menu

At Sammy's Pizza, our recipes have not changed since 1958, and additional family recipes have been added over the years. Some recipes date back to our family's original Italian restaurant opened in 1924 by our great grandparents near Iron Mountain, Michigan. Visit us to enjoy our family recipes and appetizers, soups and salads.

Homemade Soups

Cup  5.95   Bowl 6.95    Quart (to go only) 13.95

 

Cream of Potato

Homemade creamy potato soup with ham and bacon topped with cheddar cheese.

Tomato Basil

Homemade tomato soup with fresh basil topped with feta cheese.

Tortellini Soup

Homemade chicken soup with meat filled tortellini.

Soup, Salad, & Breadstick

Available until 4:00 pm

Your choice of a cup of soup, classic garden salad, and a warm breadstick. 11.45
Appetizers
Bruschetta

Slices of lightly toasted Italian bread with chopped tomato, fresh mozzarella and basil, drizzled with our balsamic glaze.

$10.45
Garlic Bread with Cheese

Toasted French bread topped with melted mozzarella cheese and served with our homemade spaghetti sauce

$8.45
Pesto Cheese Bread

Toasted French bread topped with our homemade garlic basil pesto, covered in provolone and asiago cheese served with homemade alfredo sauce.

$9.95
Garlic Bread

Toasted French bread served with our homemade spaghetti sauce.

$7.95
Breadsticks

Garlic butter breadsticks served with tomato cream sauce

$8.95
Antipasto Salad

Tomato, provolone cheese, kalamata and black olives, pepperoncini, Genoa salami, pepperoni, red onion and chick peas, served on a bed of lettuce. 

$11.95
Fresh Salads
Dressings

Homemade Vinaigrette (House Dressing) • Ranch • French • 1000 Island • Caesar • Parmesan Pepper • Honey Mustard

Bleu Cheese Crumbles

$95
Garden Salad

Mixed greens with carrots, tomatoes, cucumbers and red onions topped with fresh-made croutons.

$6.45
Chef's Salad

Ham, turkey or chicken on a bed of mixed greens, tomatoes, red onions, shredded carrots, cucumbers, cheese, and egg. Served with a warm breadstick. 14.95 Add crispy chicken

$1.45
Family Sized Salad

Large garden salad enough for four-six people with your choice of dressing.

$22.95
Avocado Salad

Our classic garden salad topped with your choice of shrimp grilled or crispy chicken, fresh avocado, tomatoes, carrots, cucumbers, red onions and hard boiled eggs served with your choice of dressing, and a warm breadstick

$15.95
Caesar Salad

Our classic Caesar salad topped with three Italian cheeses, tomatoes and fresh croutons, served with our homemade Caesar dressing.

Small - 6.45 Large - 13.95

Large is served with chicken and a breadstick

Menu

Drink

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, Diet Dr. Pepper, Mountain Dew, Diet Mountain Dew, 7up,

Mug Root Beer, and Tropicana Lemonade

Soda

  Large (Free Refills)  3.45    Pitcher   8.95

Milk and Juice
$3.45
Coffee, Hot Tea, or Hot Chocolate
$2.95
Lemonade, Iced Tea or Raspberry Iced Tea

Large (Free Refills)  3.45      Pitcher   8.45

Domestic Beer

Honey Weiss, Coors Light, Bud Light, or Miller Lite

Angry Orchard Hard Cider

Bottle   4.45

Local Craft Beer
Wisco Disco Stillmank Brewing Co.

Rich malt and hop flavors brewed with a small amount of milk sugar which provides its smooth body. A perfect match with cheese.

16 oz. 6.95 Pitcher 16.45
Rugged North Lager Copper State

Bright orange, lemony taste with a round wheat body that finishes dry. Lots of hop citrus aroma but minimal hop brightness that does not linger.

16 oz. 6.95 Pitcher 16.45
Grassy Place Hazy IPA Badger State Brewing

Smooth hop flavor and big aroma.

16 oz. 6.95 Pitcher 16.45
Johnny Blood Red Titletown Brewing Co.

Caramel malts and toasted barley. Named after Packers legend  Johnny "Blood" McNally.

16 oz. 6.45 Pitcher 15.95
Green 19 Titletown Brewing Co.

American citrus hops, balanced malt finish.

16 oz. 6.45 Pitcher 15.95
Two Stall Chocolate Milk Stout Ahnapee Brewery

Subtly sweet stout is mingled with organic roasted cacao nibs. Much more drinkable        than you assume.

16 oz. 6.95 Pitcher 16.45
Packerland Pilsner Hinterland Brewery

Malted barley, German Noble hops, and a czech pils yeast combine to create what a pilsner should be: crisp, clean and classic.

16 oz. 6.45 Pitcher 15.95
Spotted Cow New Glarus Brewing Co.

Brewed with flaked barley and the finest Wisconsin malts. Fun, fruity and satisfying.

16 oz. 6.45 Pitcher 15.95
Wine
Chardonnay Francis Coppola

Bright and balanced, highlighted by juicy apple, cantaloupe and pear flavors enveloped in a creme brulee finish.

Glass 8.45 Bottle 28.95
Chianti Giulio Straccali

Bright with youthful aromas of ripe red fruit. Medium bodied, velvety and refreshing. An ideal match for tomato-based dishes, pastas and pizzas.

Glass 7.95 Bottle 24.95
Pinot Grigio Bolla

Light and dry, with a crisp and lively taste of lemons, limes, peaches and melons.

Glass 7.45 Bottle 23.45
Fortissimo C R Cellars

A delicious dry red wine commonly described as the closet thing to homemade              Italian wine (Just like our Nono used to make).

Glass only 6.95
Trebbiano Moscato Riunite

Fruity with the haunting fragrance and flavor of the seductive Moscato grape. Soft, lively   and sweet.

Glass 6.45 Bottle 21.95
Cabernet Sauvignon Canyon Road

Medium-bodied with rich and flavorful hints of ripe raspberry and a velvety smooth finish.

Glass 5.95 Bottle 20.95
Reisling Barefoot

Delicate orange blossom aroma bounces off juicy apple and tangy lemon for                          a slightly sweet finale.

Glass 6.45 Bottle 21.95
Merlot Ravenswood

A medium-bodied, dry, juicy red with flavors of cherry, plum, and toast.

Glass 7.95 Bottle 24.95
Lambrusco Cella

Bright sparkling red wine.

Glass 5.95 Bottle 20.95

Menu

Kids

Fresh Caesar
Organic romaine lettuce, housemade croutons, grated parmesan, lemon and caesar dressing.
$12
Seasonal Greens
Roquette, grated carrots, cucumbers, sunflower seeds and balsamic dressing.
$10
French Onion Soup
Fried onion soup with Emmental and parmesan cheese.
$8
Italian Minestrone
Potatoes, zucchini, squash, celery, carrots and fresh pasta.
$8

Menu

Dessert

Cinnamon Sticks

Warm breadsticks brushed with cinnamon and butter, served with glazed icing.

3 Sticks 6.95 6 Sticks 9.95
Brownie Explosion Cheesecake

New York Style Cheesecake baked on a brownie crust loaded with mounds of brownie and chocolate on top

$7.95
New York Style Cheesecake

Creamy but not heavy, light without falling apart with rich flavor

$7.45
Tiramisu

A rich blend of cocoa, espresso, mascarpone cheese layered in a light biscuit.

$10.45
Two overlapping chat bubbles with black outline and dots inside on a white background

Here's what our satisfied customers are saying...

At Sammy’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant, we take pride in providing exceptional Italian dinners to our customers. We would be grateful if you could share your thoughts about our business with others. Your feedback helps us improve and helps others make informed decisions. Please take a moment to leave a review of Sammy’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant and let others know what you think.